The bill for Deloitte: Hacienda's ERP was failing in 2019, re-awarded in 2022, and is still stalling supplier payments
Giancarlo Gonzalez's November 13 investigation assembles the eight-year record: a $32.4 million write-off, a $73.1 million re-award that missed its deadline, and a global pattern of failed Deloitte government systems.
Puerto Rico's central government cannot pay its suppliers on time, and the backlog runs through the Treasury Department's ERP system.[1] The Department of Education has completed 91% fewer purchase orders than a year earlier.[2] The ASG had to obtain a temporary measure to keep police-cadet uniform purchases from stalling in the system.[3]
GovTech publisher Giancarlo Gonzalez - Puerto Rico's former chief information officer - laid out the record in his November 13, 2026 giangonz.com post "La factura de Deloitte": Deloitte has been implementing the Hacienda ERP since July 2018.[4] In November 2019, the project stopped six weeks short of completing its first phase, with $32.4 million disbursed.[5] The Office of the Comptroller's audit report OC-25-02, released July 8, 2024, found that the initial $32.4 million of ERP spending had produced none of the expected benefits.[6] Hacienda's response was to re-award the contract to the same company: in November 2022, Deloitte got the ERP again, for $73.1 million,[7] with a December 2024 completion deadline[8] that was missed.[9] The decisive years ran under Treasury Secretary Francisco Parés Alicea, who served from July 2019 to January 2024.[10]
The record inside the project is documented in ASG testimony presented to the Puerto Rico Senate on November 12, 2026, under Senate Resolution 429.[11] That testimony counts more than 350 ignored ERP requirements.[12] It records defect logs that Deloitte deleted during testing.[13] It shows a contract written with automatic acceptance clauses for deliverables.[14] Under those terms, each Deloitte error became another invoice to correct.[15] The system finally launched in July 2026, directly into the payment backlog now stalling suppliers.[16]
The pattern Gonzalez documents extends beyond Puerto Rico. California abandoned a Deloitte court case-management system in 2012 after nine years and roughly $500 million spent.[17] Deloitte credited Rhode Island $85.6 million for the failing UHIP benefits system,[18] and a 2024 breach using Deloitte credentials exposed the data of about 644,000 people.[19] In 2025, Deloitte refunded part of an A$440,000 Australian government report that carried AI-invented references.[20] And Newfoundland and Labrador paid Deloitte $1.6 million for a health plan with fake citations.[21]El gobierno central de Puerto Rico no puede pagar a sus proveedores a tiempo, y el atraso se origina en el sistema ERP del Departamento de Hacienda.[1] El Departamento de Educación ha procesado un 91 % menos de órdenes de compra que el año anterior.[2] La ASG tuvo que gestionar una medida temporal para evitar que la compra de uniformes para cadetes de policía se detuviera en el sistema.[3]
Giancarlo González, editor de tecnología gubernamental y exdirector de información de Puerto Rico, presentó este historial en su publicación del 13 de noviembre de 2026 en giangonz.com titulada «La factura de Deloitte»: Deloitte implementa el ERP de Hacienda desde julio de 2018.[4] En noviembre de 2019, el proyecto se detuvo seis semanas antes de finalizar su primera fase, cuando ya se habían desembolsado 32,4 millones de dólares.[5] El informe de auditoría OC-25-02 de la Contraloría, publicado el 8 de julio de 2024, determinó que ese gasto inicial no generó ninguno de los beneficios previstos para el ERP.[6] La respuesta de Hacienda fue volver a adjudicar el contrato a la misma empresa: en noviembre de 2022, Deloitte recibió nuevamente el encargo por 73,1 millones de dólares,[7] con plazo de finalización para diciembre de 2024[8] que no se cumplió.[9] Todos estos años clave transcurrieron bajo la gestión del secretario de Hacienda Francisco Parés Alicea, quien ocupó el cargo desde julio de 2019 hasta enero de 2024.[10]
Los detalles internos del proyecto están documentados en el testimonio de la ASG presentado ante el Senado de Puerto Rico el 12 de noviembre de 2026, en el marco de la Resolución Senatorial 429.[11] En dicho testimonio se contabilizan más de 350 requisitos del ERP que fueron ignorados.[12] Se registran además registros de fallos que Deloitte eliminó durante las pruebas del sistema.[13] También se evidencia que el contrato se redactó con cláusulas de aceptación automática para los entregables.[14] Bajo esas condiciones, cada error cometido por Deloitte se convirtió en una factura adicional por el trabajo de corrección.[15] El sistema se puso en funcionamiento finalmente en julio de 2026, directamente generando el atraso de pagos que actualmente afecta a los proveedores.[16]
El patrón que documenta González no se limita a Puerto Rico. California abandonó un sistema de gestión de casos judiciales de Deloitte en 2012, después de nueve años y aproximadamente 500 millones de dólares invertidos.[17] Deloitte abonó 85,6 millones de dólares a Rhode Island por fallos en el sistema de beneficios UHIP,[18] y una brecha de seguridad de 2024 mediante credenciales de la empresa expuso los datos de alrededor de 644 000 personas.[19] En 2025, Deloitte devolvió parte del pago por un informe gubernamental australiano de 440 000 dólares australianos que contenía referencias inventadas por inteligencia artificial.[20] Por su parte, Terranova y Labrador pagó 1,6 millones de dólares a Deloitte por un plan de salud con citas falsas.[21]
Proof21 sources · 2 publishers · signed
What this stands on
The government cannot pay suppliers on time. · giangonz.com
Education completed 91% fewer purchase orders than one year prior. · giangonz.com
ASG issued a temporary measure for police cadet uniform purchases. · giangonz.com
Deloitte began implementing the Hacienda ERP in July 2018. · giangonz.com
The Deloitte ERP project stopped in November 2019 with $32.4 million disbursed. · giangonz.com
Audit OC-25-02 found initial $32.4 million ERP spending had no expected benefits. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
Hacienda re-awarded the ERP contract to Deloitte in November 2022 for $73.1 million. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
The 2022 Deloitte ERP contract had a December 2024 completion deadline. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
The December 2024 ERP completion deadline was missed. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
Francisco Parés Alicea served as Hacienda secretary from July 2019 to January 2024. · giangonz.com
ASG presented testimony to Puerto Rico Senate on 2026-11-12 under R. del S. 429. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
ASG testimony documented more than 350 ignored ERP requirements. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
Deloitte errors generated correction invoices under the ERP contract. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
The ERP system launched in July 2026. · Giancarlo Gonzalez - giangonz.com (first-party capture)
California abandoned a Deloitte court system in 2012 after $500 million spent. · giangonz.com
Deloitte credited Rhode Island $85.6 million for UHIP system failures. · giangonz.com
A 2024 Rhode Island breach used Deloitte credentials to expose 644000 people's data. · giangonz.com
Deloitte refunded part of a 2025 Australian government report with fake AI references. · giangonz.com
Newfoundland and Labrador paid Deloitte $1.6 million for a health plan with fake citations. · giangonz.com
We could not place any of them by their address. None is an official body: that part stands on reporting, not on the underlying document or transcript.