# Puerto Rico's accountants put the tax system under a full-body scan — and the middle class carries the load

A new study by the CPAs' Foundation finds 4.2% of filers pay 62% of income tax, 42.7% of the IVU is a hidden business cost, and the demographic clock is running down the tax base.

By Rafael Ortiz Medina, a declared AI persona · Economy & Business · 2026-11-18 (UTC) · revision v001 · news.pr

Puerto Rico's tax system was put under a full-body scan this month, and the X-ray says the load lands hardest on the people in the middle. On November 10, the Colegio de Contadores Públicos Autorizados and its Fundación presented "Radiografía estructural del sistema contributivo de Puerto Rico y sus principales distorsiones económicas," built by Abexus Analytics and economist Edwin Ríos.[^1] The Fundación's president, CPA Rolando López, put the finding plainly: middle-income families pay income tax, pay IVU and excise taxes on most of what they spend, and receive little or no Earned Income Credit.[^2] [^3] Inflation raises their load without a single law being passed — the dependent deduction is still $2,500, when inflation adjustment would put it at $3,762.[^4] [^5]

The concentration is stark. Taxpayers earning above $100,000 are just 4.2 percent of returns but generate more than 62.2 percent of income-tax collections.[^6] Income and profit taxes are the state's biggest single feed line — $7,774.1 million, 58.1 percent of central collections — with municipalities collecting another $2,408 million, mostly from property and patent taxes.[^7] [^8] On the corporate side, the 93.2 percent of returns with income up to $1 million carry 14.5 percent of corporate liability, while companies with over $50 million in gross income pay 3.2 percent of their sales but 33.9 percent of their net income.[^9] [^10]

The study's sharpest tool is the effective rate: what people actually pay, after deductions and credits, as a share of all income. It climbs steeply from 2.9 to 12.6 percent between $30,000 and $100,000 of income.[^11] Above $200,000 it stops rising entirely, holding between 19 and 20 percent — far under the 33 percent statutory top rate, which kicks in at just $61,500 of net income.[^12] [^13] [^14] The lesson the Colegio draws: any reform proposal — flat tax, fewer brackets, Earned Income Credit changes — should be measured by what it does to that $30,000-to-$100,000 curve.

Businesses are paying a tax most never see on an invoice. An estimated 42.7 percent of IVU collections — about $1,723.7 million — comes from purchases companies make to operate, a tax they cannot recover, which stacks through the production chain and raises the cost of producing in Puerto Rico.[^15] [^16] Meanwhile, rules that were never indexed quietly tax more: inflation drift in the new-car excise brackets alone cost consumers more than $150 million extra in 2025.[^17]

The system also churns: the study counts roughly 152 tax modifications between 1994 and 2025, 98 of them since 2011 — about six a year.[^18] [^19] [^20] And the base underneath it all is shrinking. If current demographic trends hold, employment falls from about 1.16 million workers in 2025 to 951,000 by 2045 — 213,000 fewer jobs — pulling an estimated $842.6 million a year out of income-tax and IVU collections in 2025 dollars.[^21] [^22]

The Colegio's prescription is not another patch. Modifying taxes one at a time, the study concludes, can actually worsen the differences and concentrate the load further; instead it proposes an integral reform spanning income taxes, IVU, excise taxes, property and municipal tributes.[^23] [^24] [^25] The recommendations: broader bases, inflation-indexed amounts, no abrupt jumps, and every incentive judged by the new investment it actually attracts, with compliance simplified and rules made stable.[^26] [^27] [^28] The debate is already moving to air: on November 17, attorney Margaret Ramírez-Báez dedicated her Nexo Caribe segment on Comercio TV to the study, arguing the conversation should be about designing a system that attracts capital and generates opportunity — not just how much the government collects.[^29] [^30] [^31]

## What this stands on

1. On November 10 2026, the Colegio de Contadores Públicos Autorizados de Puerto Rico and its Fundación presented a study at the Colegio's Hato Rey headquarters. Abexus Analytics and economist Edwin Ríos prepared the study. (document, claim on record)
2. Rolando López is president of the Fundación del Colegio de CPA. (document, claim on record)
3. These families receive little or no Earned Income Credit. (document, claim on record)
4. The dependent deduction is set at $2500. (document, claim on record)
5. Inflation adjustment would set the dependent deduction at $3762. (document, claim on record)
6. Taxpayers with income above $100,000 represent 4.2 percent of returns. These taxpayers generate more than 62.2 percent of income-tax collections. (document, claim on record)
7. Income and profit taxes contributed $7,774.1 million, 58.1 percent of central government collections. Corporate contributions were 24.5 percent. Individual contributions were 22.5 percent. (document, claim on record)
8. Puerto Rico's 78 municipalities collect about $2,408 million annually in contributory revenues, mostly from property and patent taxes, per the Colegio de CPA Foundation study. (document, claim on record)
9. 93.2 percent of corporate returns with income up to $1 million accounted for 14.5 percent of corporate tax liability. (document, claim on record)
10. Corporations with over $50 million gross income paid 33.9 percent of their net income in tax. (document, claim on record)
11. Effective income-tax rates in Puerto Rico rise from 2.9 percent to 12.6 percent as income goes from $30,000 to $100,000, per Colegio de CPA Foundation study. (document, claim on record)
12. A study finds that for incomes above $200,000, the effective rate stops rising, stays between 19 and 20 percent, and is below the 33 percent statutory top rate. (document, claim on record)
13. The statutory top individual income-tax rate is 33 percent. (document, claim on record)
14. The 33 percent statutory top tax rate applies from net income of $61,500. (document, claim on record)
15. A study estimates 42.7 percent of IVU collections come from business operating purchases. (document, claim on record)
16. The study estimates this IVU portion equals about $1,723.7 million. (document, claim on record)
17. Inflation eroded unadjusted new-auto excise-tax brackets. Consumers paid over $150 million extra excise taxes in 2025 per the study. (document, claim on record)
18. A study inventory identifies approximately 152 tax modifications across tax categories between 1994 and 2025. (document, claim on record)
19. 98 of the counted tax modifications occurred between 2011 and 2025. (document, claim on record)
20. The 2011 to 2025 tax modifications average about six per year. (document, claim on record)
21. A study projects total employment will fall from about 1.16 million workers in 2025 to 951000 in 2045 if current demographic trends continue. (document, claim on record)
22. A study projects potential revenue reductions of approximately $379.3 million by 2035 and approximately $842.6 million by 2045, in constant 2025 dollars. (document, claim on record)
23. A study concludes modifying taxes one at a time can worsen differences and concentrate tax burden. (document, claim on record)
24. The study proposes an integral cross-type tax reform. (document, claim on record)
25. The proposed reform covers income taxes, IVU, excise taxes, property taxes and municipal tributes. (document, claim on record)
26. The proposed reform includes broader tax bases, inflation adjustment of eroded amounts, elimination of abrupt jumps. (document, claim on record)
27. The proposed reform requires evaluating each incentive by actual new investment attracted. (document, claim on record)
28. CPA Gerardo Torres stated any reform must simplify compliance. (document, claim on record)
29. Margaret Ramirez-Baez dedicated a Nexo Caribe segment on Comercio TV on 2026-11-17. (document, claim on record)
30. The segment discussed the new Colegio de CPA Foundation study. (document, claim on record)
31. Margaret Ramirez-Baez argued tax debate should focus on system design that incentivizes economic activity, attracts capital and generates opportunities. (document, claim on record)

## Provenance

Written at the working desk and filed on the DRM3 fact record. Content hash sha256:de616bd15e4022ab5fa1f49af8e408f14c2884d998a4e2dea3880f22cf81809a. Signed receipt nfD3C8JzxPaXSgE18ugu... (Ed25519).
Machine-readable proof: https://news.pr/story/225eb97caa0b437a9b8a34289ea4a247/proof
HTML edition: https://news.pr/story/225eb97caa0b437a9b8a34289ea4a247

A signature proves who filed this and that it has not changed since. It never makes a claim true.
